Does this sound familiar?
You have made an impressive presentation with lots of data and charts. You have analyzed the data so well to arrive at some really amazing conclusions. You have included several pie charts since they are easy to digest. You thought your audience are going to love it.
But your pie charts failed to evoke any response.
How to make your pie charts likable ?
Well, you don’t really want them to like your charts, you want them to like your insights, your ideas.
But, to get there, you need to shake up your audience, so that they take notice of what your charts are saying.
A simple trick for achieving this is showing charts in different formats (while retaining the meaning).
Here we will see 9 creative ways to alter your pie charts so that they can start a conversation.
- Get some bottom aligned bubbles
Bottom aligned bubbles are a new fad in visualization. You can do them by using Excel’s bubble chart. Convert the pie values in to a bubble chart. Change the X and Y co-ordinates to align the bubbles at bottom. - How about concentric circles
Concentric circles can be a good alternative to pie chart and they are very easy to do using excel’s built in bubble chart. Just make all the X and Y co-ordinates as same. - Why not slices instead of pies
Using slices instead of pies is another simple and intuitive visualization trick. For this we can use bubble chart with axis adjustments so that bottom half of the bubbles is cropped. - Use a radar chart tweak
Using Excel Radar Chart, you can make a cool alternative to pie chart. Simply copy paste the pie chart values in to few more columns (you are seeing the result of 8 columns) and fire up a radar chart with area. - A stacked bar is often tastier
Of course, the simplest and most elegant of them all, a stacked bar chart. This is also very easy to implement. - Or even a regular bar chart
- Use a tree map
Using a non-hierarchical tree map to replace pie charts is a good idea. Unfortunately making the same in excel is a bit of manual job (or VBA). For smaller set of values, the manual job is worth the effect.A simple alternative to manual job is to use Many Eye’s tree map tool
- If circle is hard to swallow, a Square Pie can Help
Square pies are a simpler alternative to pie charts. They are easy to develop using conditional formatting. Here is a tutorial. - Show them in a tag cloud
Tag clouds are a famous visualization technique. They are very easy to do (either manually or automated) in Excel. Here is a tutorial for Excel tag cloud visualization.
Added later: All these charts are effective for fewer values (<6) and with data labels.
What is your favorite Pie chart alternative?
Also check out, 14 different ways to present same data
15 Responses to “Christmas Gift List – Set your budget and track gifts using Excel”
[...] Christmas Gift List – Set your budget and track gifts using Excel … [...]
I'm confused: if you spend $10, and your budget is $40, shouldn't the amount in the "Within Budget?" column stay black, since you didn't go over budget?
In other words, since we overspent on the electronic photo frame, shouldn't the $8 cell turn red?
@JP.. maybe Steven is encouraging consumerism... ?
I havent realized it earlier, but now I see it. If you unprotect the sheet, you can change the formula in Column I to =IF(G13=0;" ";F13-G13) from =IF(G13=0;" ";G13-F13), that should correct the behavior.
Thanks Chandoo. I thought of making a shopping list spreadsheet for Christmas, but this is neat so I think I'll use this instead.
Chandoo & Steven thanks for this spreadsheet. But for the sake of a person who has been staring at this megaformula in vain for the last 40 mins and not afraid to ask, would it be possible for you to walk us through the logic used here?
=SUM(SUMPRODUCT(SUBTOTAL(3,OFFSET($K$13:$K$62,ROW($K$13:$K$62)-MIN(ROW($K$13:$K$62)),0,1)),--($K$13:$K$62="-"))+SUMPRODUCT(SUBTOTAL(3,OFFSET($K$13:$K$62,ROW($K$13:$K$62)-MIN(ROW($K$13:$K$62)),0,1)),--($K$13:$K$62="0")))&" / "&SUBTOTAL(2,$G$13:$G$62)
Thanks Chandoo.. This is one of the best budget spreadsheets I've ever seen.. The Arrays are out of this world!! And it's FREE!!
Chandoo, can you tell us more about Steven? Does he have his own site?
JP, I think Chandoo changed it when he changed the currency formatting from £ to $, a negative figure is a good thing in this case. But don't change the formulas, the overbudget and under budget won't work properly if you do. Also Chandoo I think you've accidentally broke the conditional formatting for the alternating row colouring the formula is different to the version I sent you. As for the megaformula chrisham, it gave me a headache trying to get it all working, so I will let Chandoo talk you through it.
Hi,
In cells I6 and I7, I understand that subtotal together with offset function returns an array of ones after which, the sumproduct function gives the desired result.
But I’m not able to figure out the reason for using an array in I8 to return the most expensive gift.
Can’t the formula be just
“=VLOOKUP(SUBTOTAL(4,$G$13:$G$62),$G$13:$J$62,4,0)”
Savithri, Cell I8 needs the array, if the formula was “=VLOOKUP(SUBTOTAL(4,$G$13:$G$62),$G$13:$J$62,4,0)” it would find the highest price from the filtered range (i.e. highest actual in filtered range is $50) BUT then return the first person with that actual, not looking in just the filtered range (so first person on the list with a $50 actual.)
To see what I mean, change the formula, then change all the actuals to $50 then filter for baby, it lists the first name on the list.
But a good question 🙂
Thank you. I now realise that the array is used to get the ‘filtered range’ instead of the entire range, as table array for look up value.
[...] Download This Template [...]
this looks like an awesome excel sheet!! is there anyway i can get it emailed to me unprotected? for some reason, i am unable to download it 🙁 help!!
Hi I also can not download to a mac as the sheet is protected any help would be great
[...] to send her a pricey present. Rather, send a card with a picture of your child. Here’s a cool Excel sheet that will help you estimate your budget per person and let you track [...]
[...] husband and I pour/poor over the Christmas spreadsheet (yes, I do know how dorky that sounds, but we’re not the only ones!), figuring out who should give what to whom. We live at a distance from most of our family, so it [...]