Calculating Maximum Change [solutions & discussion]
Last Friday, we had a fun little Excel challenge – Calculate Maximum Change. More than 170 people commented and shared their solutions to this problem.
And the best part?
The best part is the variety of solutions & thinking displayed by our community. So if you are one of those 170, puff your chest & pat yourself on the back. Go ahead, I will wait.
Today, lets take a look at some of these awesome formulas and understand how they work. Read on and watch the video you below to gain few awesomeness pounds.
First, lets understand the problem
Here is a look at the problem:
We need more information to answer this question.
 Are we talking about positive change, negative change or absolute change?
 Are we talking about % change or value change?
In the original problem, even though I did not mention it, most people assumed that we want absolute change of value (ie the answer is 40, for Product 2).
But in real life, you may want to understand the problem a little more before writing any formulas.
Note: The data is in C3:C8 for last month and D3:D8 for this month.
Solution #1: Using MAX array formula
This is the solution most people got.
The array formula:
=MAX(C3:C8D3:D8)
press CTRL+Shift+Enter after typing.
How it works?
C3:C8D3:D8 portion: This gives the result {20;40;15;21;0;25} in array form.MAX(…) portion: This simply calculates the maximum value of above array and returns 40 as answer.
Why press CTRL+Shift+Enter (CSE)?
We need to press CTRL+Shift+Enter because MAX() is not capable of handling arrays. If you write MAX({20;40;15;21;0;25}) you would get 40, but the same array when calculated by doing math on ranges will not work. To force MAX to treat arrays, we need to press CTRL+Shift+Enter.
Solution #2: Using MAX+ABS array formula
Quite a few people figured out that the formula needs to work even when the change is negative. And that is where this new solution comes handy.
The array formula:
=MAX(ABS(C3:C8D3:D8))
press CTRL+Shift+Enter after typing.
How it works?
ABS() portion: converts the change values {20;40;15;21;0;25} to positive {20;40;15;21;0;25}
Rest of the formula is same as solution #1.
Solution #3: Using INDEX to avoid Ctrl+Shift+Enter
The thing with Ctrl+Shift+Enter is that you have to remember it. If you accidentally press Enter instead of CSE, the formula stops working. One way to avoid this is to route the calculation thru an Excel function that can natively process arrays. This is where INDEX (or SUMPRODUCT etc.) come handy.
The formula:
=MAX(INDEX(C3:C8D3:D8,0))
or
=MAX(INDEX(ABS(C3:C8D3:D8),0))
How it works?
Same as Solution #1, except for this formula you do not have to press Ctrl+Shift+Enter. The INDEX will automatically calculate the array and send numbers to MAX. Then MAX feels mighty comfortable dealing with those numbers and spits out the answer as 40.
Learn more:
Solution #4: Using AGGREGATE
AGGREGATE() is a new function introduced in Excel 2010. This too, like INDEX & SUMPRODUCT can process arrays natively (provided you are using one of the aggregates like LARGE). Kyle, one of our commenters shared 2 brilliant solutions that involve AGGREGATE.
The formula:
=AGGREGATE(14,4,(C3:C8)(D3:D8),1)
How it works?
14, 4 portion: This tells AGGREGATE that you want to calculate LARGE value (14) and you want to consider all cells (4). To understand more about AGGREGATE see the links below.
(C3:C8)(D3:D8) portion: As seen above, this just gives an array – {20;40;15;21;0;25}
1 portion: This tells AGGREGATE that you want 1st largest number.
Learn more:
Solution #5: Using MMULT and AGGREGATE
Now this is what I call a scary formula. It can potentially waste your entire afternoon when you try to understand it first time. But once you get it, you feel awesome. This too is posted by Kyle.
The formula:
=AGGREGATE(14,4,MMULT(C3:D8,{1;1}),1)
How it works?
Watch the video. Explaining how this works in text is difficult.
Learn more:
I am still trying to understand MMULT(). It can be as complex and deep as string theory (or recipe of making bread at home). Go thru below links to learn more about it. Make sure you put on your helmet, cause it will blow your mind.
More ways to get maximum change + Bonus problem
Watch below video to understand how to solve the maximum change problem and another related problem.
Click here to watch if you can’t see the video above
Download Answer workbook
Click here to download answer workbook and examine the formulas to learn more.
What did you learn from this formula challenge?
I learned how to use AGGREGATE, Array SUMIFS and got a better handle on MMULT.
What about you? What did you learn thru this challenge. Please comment and let us all know.
 
 

Leave a Reply
Why you should close down Excel completely  CP003: Business Intelligence for Masses – Interview with Mike Alexander 
11 Responses to “Calculating Maximum Change [solutions & discussion]”
I disagree with all of the answers in your workbook. In the real world a product manager would want to know if the largest change was a negative or positive change. What good is it for a manager to know the absolute change when making decisions as to which product he/she wants to keep in stock or produce more. If answer is 40 not 40.
This formula gives the real number instead of the absolute change:
{=INDEX(C3:C8D3:D8C3:C8,MATCH(MAX(ABS(C3:C8D3:D8)),ABS(C3:C8D3:D8),0))}
When I tried your formula I get 80. What am I missing.
My original posts:
{=IF(ABS(MIN(D3:D8C3:C8))>MAX(D3:D8C3:C8),MIN(D3:D8C3:C8),MAX(D3:D8C3:C8))}
And For Product:
{=INDEX($B$3:$B$8,MATCH(IF(ABS(MIN(D3:D8C3:C8))>MAX(D3:D8C3:C8),MIN(D3:D8C3:C8),MAX(D3:D8C3:C8)),D3:D8C3:C8,0))}
This is a nice introduction to the ctrl+shift+enter for arrays. They are something I am aware of but rarely get around to applying. The combination of max and abs might be useful for me in analysing forecasts where I am interested in absolute variations over a period. The aggregate and index will be a topic for another rainy day.
[…] http://chandoo.org/wp/2014/03/26/maximumchangesolutions/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=emai… […]
Excellent post as always Chandoo ! Your website is what got me hooked to using excel more and more in the first place…and now every data problem I see, I itch to open my excel sheet for solving it Its a holy grail for excel enthusiasts Thankyou for being so awesome !!
A question on the above solution. How do we work the formula when it is max percentage change we are looking to find?? I tried some permutations combinations but dsnt seem to be working
Awesome! I also tried few things. I have to agree with DON about knowing if the value is negative or positive. Also one point would be knowing that what is the product that gives the difference.
So i placed in C11 =IF(ABS(MAX(INDEX($C$3:$C$8$D$3:$D$8;0)))>ABS(MIN(INDEX($C$3:$C$8$D$3:$D$8;0)));MAX(INDEX($C$3:$C$8$D$3:$D$8;0));MIN(INDEX($C$3:$C$8$D$3:$D$8;0)))
And in C12
=INDEX($B$3:$D$8;MATCH(IF(ABS(MAX(INDEX($C$3:$C$8$D$3:$D$8;0)))>ABS(MIN(INDEX($C$3:$C$8$D$3:$D$8;0)));MAX(INDEX($C$3:$C$8$D$3:$D$8;0));MIN(INDEX($C$3:$C$8$D$3:$D$8;0)));INDEX($C$3:$C$8$D$3:$D$8;0);0);1)
This would find the maximum change in C11 and give the product that has the maximum change in C12.
For the percentile I would use (the percentile calculations in D11 & D12, format of D11 percent)
D11
=IF(ABS(MAX(INDEX((1($C$3:$C$8/$D$3:$D$8));0)))>ABS(MIN(INDEX((1($C$3:$C$8/$D$3:$D$8));0)));MAX(INDEX((1($C$3:$C$8/$D$3:$D$8));0));MIN(INDEX((1($C$3:$C$8/$D$3:$D$8));0)))
D12
=INDEX($B$3:$D$8;MATCH(IF(ABS(MAX(INDEX((1($C$3:$C$8/$D$3:$D$8));0)))>ABS(MIN(INDEX((1($C$3:$C$8/$D$3:$D$8));0)));MAX(INDEX((1($C$3:$C$8/$D$3:$D$8));0));MIN(INDEX((1($C$3:$C$8/$D$3:$D$8));0)));INDEX((1($C$3:$C$8/$D$3:$D$8));0);0);1)
Wow, that was longer than expected.
What do you think?
Uups. I had my columns mixed. I had this month in column C and last in column D. Also the percentile calculations are wrong.
Here are the corrected formulas:
C11
=IF(ABS(MAX(INDEX($D$3:$D$8$C$3:$C$8;0)))>ABS(MIN(INDEX($D$3:$D$8$C$3:$C$8;0)));MAX(INDEX($D$3:$D$8$C$3:$C$8;0));MIN(INDEX($D$3:$D$8$C$3:$C$8;0)))
C12
=INDEX($B$3:$D$8;MATCH(IF(ABS(MAX(INDEX($D$3:$D$8$C$3:$C$8;0)))>ABS(MIN(INDEX($D$3:$D$8$C$3:$C$8;0)));MAX(INDEX($D$3:$D$8$C$3:$C$8;0));MIN(INDEX($D$3:$D$8$C$3:$C$8;0)));INDEX($D$3:$D$8$C$3:$C$8;0);0);1)
D11
=IF(ABS(MAX(INDEX((($D$3:$D$8/$C$3:$C$8)1);0)))>ABS(MIN(INDEX((($D$3:$D$8/$C$3:$C$8)1);0)));MAX(INDEX((($D$3:$D$8/$C$3:$C$8)1);0));MIN(INDEX((($D$3:$D$8/$C$3:$C$8)1);0)))
D12
=INDEX($B$3:$D$8;MATCH(IF(ABS(MAX(INDEX((($D$3:$D$8/$C$3:$C$8)1);0)))>ABS(MIN(INDEX((($D$3:$D$8/$C$3:$C$8)1);0)));MAX(INDEX((($D$3:$D$8/$C$3:$C$8)1);0));MIN(INDEX((($D$3:$D$8/$C$3:$C$8)1);0)));INDEX((($D$3:$D$8/$C$3:$C$8)1);0);0);1)
I hope they are correct this time around.
What do you think?
[…] challenged us to solve an Excel problem, and find the products with the maximum change in monthly sales. There were 170 comments, with a wide variety of […]
Hi Chandoo,
One more simple formula: ‘Large’ which is array entered.
i.e. =large(ABS(C3:C8D3:D8),1) array entered.