• Hi All

    Please note that at the Chandoo.org Forums there is Zero Tolerance to Spam

    Post Spam and you Will Be Deleted as a User

    Hui...

  • When starting a new post, to receive a quicker and more targeted answer, Please include a sample file in the initial post.

Bell curve with plot points overlay

gtothek

Member
Hello

How can I chart a bell curve and then also show the plot points as an overlay? I have numerous employee scores that I would like to show standard deviation (bell curve) and then the individual scores as scattered plot points along the bell curve. Is this possible? Thanks in advance for your help!
 
Hello, how are you creating the bell curve? Can you post a sample file with some anonymised employee scores?
 
How about this ?
upload_2015-6-8_9-53-55.png
see attached file:
 

Attachments

  • Normal_curve.xlsx
    13.2 KB · Views: 109
yes Hui, something to this effect. I actually don't have my data yet, I will let you know if I have further questions. Thank you for your help!
 
Here is a sample of the data I'm trying to chart. It's not "completing" the bell curve. The score range is from 0-4. Why won't the data curve out the bell? Is it the way my graph axises are set up?
 

Attachments

  • bell curve.xlsx
    14.6 KB · Views: 24
Hows this:
upload_2015-6-9_8-45-55.png
What i have plotted is the Normal Curve that fits your Meand and Std Dev (Blue Line)
Your data mapped onto the Normal Curve Red Crosses

The Blue Circles is the distribution of your data
You can see that it naturally isn't a great fit to a normal distribution.
It has a large number of entries at or just above the mean with no upper outliers and a few lower outliers


See attached file:
 

Attachments

  • Normal_curve2.xlsx
    16.1 KB · Views: 91
Hows this:
View attachment 19642
What i have plotted is the Normal Curve that fits your Meand and Std Dev (Blue Line)
Your data mapped onto the Normal Curve Red Crosses

The Blue Circles is the distribution of your data
You can see that it naturally isn't a great fit to a normal distribution.
It has a large number of entries at or just above the mean with no upper outliers and a few lower outliers


See attached file:
Could you explain in more detail what you have charted? What is the bell curve? is it columns N and O on the spreadsheet? How did you plot the actual points on the bell curve for employee scores?
 
Normal Distributions, sometimes called Bell curves, are a standard curve defined by two values, the Mean and Standard Deviation (SD).
Refer: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normal_distribution

Your data has a mean of 3.47 and a SD of 0.561447

This means that data has an average of 3.47 and that 99.7% of the data will be between Mean - 3 x SD and Mean + 3 x SD = 1.78 - 5.15
The Blue line is the Normal curve for the Mean and SD used based on you data
The Blue line is not based on a range but is calculated using Named Formula specifically x and y

Your data has been plotted as Circles
Each circle is plotted from Column N & P
N is known as a bucket list, specifically it is a collection of buckets which is used to tally (Column O) the values that surround each centroid
eg: the Value 3.6 (N16) has 5 values in +/- 0.1 from 3.6
so between 3.5 and 3.7 there are 5 values in your original list from Column K

Column P is purely the frequency of column O ie: Bucket Count / Total Count

You can see that the circles on the chart don't forma smooth curve as the blue line does, in fact it is heavily weighted between 3.4 and 4.0 with a small tail around 2.4-2.6
This may be either because :
1. There is only 20 data points or
2. The data may not be Normally Distributed

The Red Crosses simply show where each data point falls on the Normal Curve, supporting that the sample size may not be normal as discussed above

I am not a statistician or mathematician and so you should probably do some more research on this if you are going to start modelling something based on a Normal Curve of this data.
 
Thanks Hui for your thorough explanation. I was wondering specifically how you got the bell curve to form so nicely on the graph? When I plotted the data, it did not round out the bottom of the curve, it looked more like a hook than a bell. Do I need to add buckets to my data? I will be recreating this report, so that's why I need to understand how to graph it to make it look like yours :)
 
The bell curve is a Named Formula X with values Y
X is calculated by setting up 40 buckets between - 4 x SD and + 4 x SD
the for each bucket value calculating the Inverse Normal Distribution
Then Excel simply fits a smooth line between the 40 data points

upload_2015-6-9_23-31-27.png
I have uploaded a sample file where the Normal Chart is done using ranges as shown above
 

Attachments

  • Normal_curve2.xlsx
    20.6 KB · Views: 76
Success! I got the graph to work! Thanks so much for your help! I didn't realize I needed to plot the bell curve with the st dev range and bucket size and then overlay the scores.
 
I have sales representative data for last 9months I want to show that data in bell curve type of chart. so what can I do for that.

Please help me on the same
 

Attachments

  • New salesman all sales.xls
    85 KB · Views: 19
Back
Top