I've composed a formula similar to Luke's (see attached file):
=INDEX($L$3:$N$33,SUMPRODUCT(($G$3:$G$33=A3)*($H$3:$H$33<=B3)*($I$3:$I$33>=B3)*($J$3:$J$33<=C3)*($K$3:$K$33>=C3)*ROW($L$3:$N$33))-2,MATCH(D3,{0,10001,25001}))
Note: In the third row of sample data you provided, both Luke and I are...