# Charting Lessons from Optical Illusions

Posted on July 28th, 2009 in Charts and Graphs , Featured - 7 comments

The other day while doing aimless roaming on the dotcom alley, I have seen some cool optical illusions. There are so many valuable lessons optical illusions can teach us – chart makers. Don’t believe me? Read on…

### We cant measure sizes either

Much has been said about our inability to measure angles. That is why most of the charting gurus recommend you to not use pie charts. But what about sizes? Well, it seems we are bad at measuring them too. Look at this illusion.

Both the orange circles are of same size.  As you can see, they don’t look so. I call this a bubble chart illusion.

What can this illusion teach us?

• Use data labels
• When you make a big chart, the neighbors of a data element determine how they are perceived. Avoid this illusion by adjusting axis, rearranging data or using color.

### Colors are what we think they are

We talk alot about colors in charting. But when it comes to interpreting colors, our mind is very subjective. Look at this color illusion.

Can you believe both cells A and B are of the same color?

What can this illusion teach us?

• Use fewer colors when possible. Better still use one color.
• When you need to use multiple colors, make them distinct. If you use shades of same color, make sure they are not poorly juxtaposed.

### Too much data can create un-necessary patterns

Look at this optical illusion that looks like a stacked bar chart. See how the lines don’t seem parallel.

I am sure some of you would have seen a stacked bar with enough data that looks closely like the above illusion.

What can this illusion teach us?

• If you are plotting too much data on a chart, make sure the chart is readable.
• Dont place chart elements (bars in this case) close to each other, don’t separate them too much either.

### Gray color messes with our gray matter

There are just so many optical illusions involving gray color that I don’t know where to begin. See this for eg.

Because of its neither here nor there nature, gray color can easily mess with our mind (and eyes). One reason why excel 2003 and earlier charts looked so ugly is because of the gray color. They had that as default background.

What can this illusion teach us?

### No matter what your chart says, your audience will see what they want

You might think your chart proves pattern A. But your audience only see the pattern B. For eg. look at this illusion:

Some people instantly see a flower vase. Others see 2 faces. And this could be true for your charts.

What can this illusion teach us?

• Don’t leave the messages for interpretation. Spell them out if you can.

### We over estimate our memory power

Our mind is notoriously forgetful and unlearns things so fast. Don’t trust me? Well, see this animated illusion.

Both yellow lines are of same length. But the moment the guiding lines are removed our mind tends to think first line is smaller than the next one. Add the guiding lines again and our mind quickly learns the fact that they are of same length. Remove it and it is as if we never learned the fact. In this great TED talk, the speaker Dan Ariely talks about the same and asks whether our mind is in complete control of the decisions we make.

What can this illusion teach us?

• Next time you set out to make that 50 slide presentation, remember this: “we are poor at remembering things”
• Use data labels, keep things simple and together if you can.

### No one talks about a chart, but everyone talks about an illusion

Well, what can I say. I look at at least a dozen charts everyday. And yet, here I am, talking about optical illusions. That is true for most of us. We like magic, we like wonderful things and want to talk about them. We have seen one too many charts that they don’t excite us anymore. Show me an optical illusion and I am ready to stare at the black dot for 30 seconds. Show me a pie chart and I am yawning already.

What can this teach us?

• Whenever you can, tell a great story.
• Connect with your audience in unusual and exciting ways.
• Break some rules and don’t be shy to add a spark.

### Introducing our Online Power BI Class:

Would you like to join me on a date with Power BI? In this comprehensive online class, learn all about Power BI so you can create beautiful, insightful & interactive reports. Join me and rest of the play mates for our first ever Power BI Play Date.

 Introducing PHD Forums (and some other updates) Build a Retirement Calculator using Excel (learn how to use Goal Seek as a bonus)

### 7 Responses to “Charting Lessons from Optical Illusions”

1. Chandoo says:

Doh.. I forget to acknowledge the original images of these illusions. all of them (except the stacked bar chart illusion) are from Wikimedia. Original images can be found here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_illusion

I will update the post later in the evening...

2. Andreas says:

Hi Chandoo,

Another interesting (Excel) optical illusion is the so-called Hermann Grid illusion:

http://blog.xlcubed.com/hermann-grids-an-optical-illusion-best-avoided/

Andreas

3. Modeste says:

Hi shandoo...

another well known great illusion...
;o))

cherrio

Great post Chandoo! While I try keep in mind many of the mantras of good charting (e.g., data-to-ink ratio, spare use of color, etc.) these illusions illustrate the importance of avoiding a seemingly different breed of problem. Our vision can truly do some strange things!

5. Jeff Weir says:

Cool! All of these would make great tshirt designs Chandoo...perhaps you should sell some via the site.

• Chandoo says:

Excellent... T-shirts, eh? I will tell Smithers to take a look at this 😛

6. [...] Charting Lessons from Optical Illusions [...]

 Introducing PHD Forums (and some other updates) Build a Retirement Calculator using Excel (learn how to use Goal Seek as a bonus)